Some comparisons of current Sway versus i3 behavior:
1) T[T[T[app]]] + move left
* Sway: T[app]
* i3: T[T[app]]
2) H[V[H[V[app]]]] + move left
* Sway: H[app]
* i3: H[V[app]]
After this commit, Sway behavior matches i3. The intermediate states
are now:
T[T[T[app]]] -> T[T[app T[]]] -> T[T[app]]
H[V[H[V[app]]]] -> H[V[app H[V[]]]] -> H[V[app]]
In i3 the layout command on a workspace affects the workspace layout
only on empty workspaces. Otherwise children are placed in a new
container with the desired layout to preserve the workspace layout.
Instead of letting wlroots print messages to stdout, route debugging
messages into Sway's logging functions. This allows a more consistent
output (e.g. if Sway or wlroots changes its output style, they don't get
out-of-sync).
I also added a [wlr] prefix to wlroots messages, not yet sure it's a
good thing.
For each following combinations of criteria & command below, the command would
crash sway without the fix.
It's particular about the __focused__ criteria, where the view matches part of
the criteria but not the focused app, leading to a failure when calling
`strcmp` with NULL.
"xterm" is a non-wayland app (X11) and "kitty" is. Both are terminals.
# "class" is specific to X11
# The view is X11 (xterm) leading to the criteria checking for the
# focused app's class, leading to a crash
for_window [class="__focused__"] floating enable
exec kitty -e xterm
# Similarly, crash as the focused app (xterm) has no app_id when the view has one
for_window [app_id="__focused__"] floating enable
exec xterm -e kitty
# If the view has a title but not the focused app: NULL title will crash criteria checking
for_window [title="__focused__"] floating enable
exec xterm -title "" -e xterm
Currently, when sway sends a configure with some geometry and the
client responds with a different geometry in a commit that acks that
configure, sway ignores the new size. Sway applies the surface
geometry it had requested to the container, not what was actually
committed, in the following transaction.
This change allows any client commit to change its surface geometry,
even if it is a response to a configure event.
The keyboard group's effective keyboard layout was never being changed
due to a condition that incorrectly preventing it from being performed.
The IPC event that follows the change was correctly being prevented.
To query whether a container is sticky, checking `con->is_sticky` is
insufficient. `container_is_floating_or_child` must also return true;
this led to a lot of repetition.
This commit introduces `container_is_sticky[_or_child]` functions, and
switches all stickiness checks to use them. (Including ones where the
container is already known to be floating, for consistency.)
Previously, `find_edge` on a single fullscreen view would occasionally
return an edge rather than `WLR_EDGE_NONE`. This would trigger entry
into `seatop_resize_tiling`, which doesn't have meaning for a fullscreen
view.
The result was that the fullscreen container hitbox was considered to be
that of where it'd be if it were tiling, so most clicks would not go
through.
Fixes#5792.
When scrolling on a tabbed/stacked container, i3 focuses its
inactive-focused focused child. Sway does the same, but then resets the
focus to whatever was focused previously.
Ref e5992eed16/src/click.c (L207-L219)
The function evacuate_sticky() was changed in commit 32788a93 to be used
by workspace_for_each_container() to make the code more readable. But I
overlooked that it is not safe to use workspace_for_each_container() to
remove container from a workspace. This commit restores the previous
implementation for evacuate_sticky().
Currently, when a floating container with a view is split and
children are added to it, the new views are rendered as tiled,
while the first view stays in floating style.
Here this is addressed by setting the view to tiled as soon
as the container is split, by duplicating the "view part" of
the logic in container_set_floating(..., false). Since the new
container of the view is no longer considered floating, it
makes sense to set the view to tiling at this point.
The view would have to be set back to floating if it was possible
to "unsplit" the container.
Sticky floating containers on an otherwise empty workspace can only be
evacuated if the new output has an active workspace. The noop output may
not have one and in that case we have to move the whole workspace to the
new output.
Currently, in view_autoconfigure, the only condition for show_border
is !view_is_only_visible. view_is_only_visible does not cross the
boundary between the workspace's tiling and floating lists and does not
differentiate between them.
The result is, that in a workspace with zero or more tiling containers
and a single floating container, the floating container will lose its
borders as soon as it is split, provided that a only one view is visible
within the floating container.
Fixed by adjusting the condition for show_borders.
A "resize shrink width 1px" will cause grow_x to be 0 while grow_width is -1,
incorrectly rejecting the command even though the resize is not a noop. Fix
this by checking width/height instead of x/y.
Sway maintains a list of pending transactions, and tries to merge
consecutive transactions applying to the same views into one. Given
a pending transactions list on views {A, B, C} of:
A -> A' -> A'' -> B -> B' -> B''
Sway will collapse the transactions into just A'' -> B''. This works
fine when doing things like resizing views by their border. However,
when interactively resizing layouts like H[V[A B] C], we end up with
pending transaction lists like:
A -> B -> C -> A' -> B' -> C' -> A'' -> B'' -> C''
Previously, Sway would not be able to simplify this transaction list,
and execute many more transactions than would be necessary (the final
state is determined by {A'', B'', C''}).
After this commit, the transaction list gets simplified to A'' -> B'' ->
C'', resolving performance problems (that were particularly noticeable
with high-refresh-rate mice).
Fixes#5736.
Xwayland views are aware of their coordinates, so validating transaction
completions should take into account the reported coordinates of the
view. Prior to this commit they didn't, and matching dimensions would
suffice to validate the transaction.
Also introduced `transaction_notify_view_ready_immediately` to support
the fix from d0f7e0f without jumping through hoops to figure out the
geometry of an `xdg_shell` view.
Sway logical coordinates are doubles, but they get truncated to integers
when sent to Xwayland through `xcb_configure_window`. X11 apps will not
respond to duplicate configure requests (from their truncated point of
view) and cause transactions to time out.
Fixes#5035.
Prior to this commit, having a layout like T[app1 V[app2]], focusing
app2, and then doing `move left` would result in T[app2 app1]. Now, the
resulting layout is T[app1 app2], which matches i3 behavior.
`container_flatten` updates `container->parent`, meaning that the
existing check would never be true.
i3 shows indicators for the workspace-level pseudo-split, but Sway does
not, as of b977c02. This commit replaces the floating container check
with a call to `container_is_floating`, which has some more robust
checks in place.
Fixes#5699.
We can't arm the timer during cursor creation since the config may not
be ready yet. Instead arm the timer while applying the input
configuration, by this time the configuration has been parsed and we can
arm the hide timer.
Fixes#5686
According to the wayland docs, wayland timers are disarmed on creation.
This leads to the cursor not being hidden if there is no activity after
creation, since the timer is armed on activity, but not at creation.
Arm the timer after creation to ensure the cursor is hidden even if
there is no cursor activity after creation.
Fixes#5684
Reset the event source after unhiding the cursor, to ensure that the
timeout starts after showing the cursor. Also remove the open coded
variant in seat_consider_warp_to_focus().
Fixes#5679
My primary issue was IntelliJ IDEA's code suggestion pop-up not returning focus
to the active editing window.
I have spent some time looking at the changes of @Xyene (#5398) and
@RyanDwyer (#2103). I think my proposed change maintains the status
quo for the most part whilst fixing my focus issue.
I have verified that @Xyene's fix for IntelliJ sub-menus still works.
I have done basic testing which consists of:
- Chrome
- IntelliJ IDEA 2020.2.1
- VSCode
- Alacritty
It seems to hold up. I at least didn't see any obvious errors.
Relates to #3007
This changes it so all libinput config options are set on any device
that supports it. Previously, only a subset of libinput config options
were being considered depending on the input type. Instead of trying to
guess which properties the device may support, attempt to set any
configured property regardless of the device type. All of the functions
already have early returns in them for when the device does not actually
support the property. This brings the configuration side inline with
describe_libinput_device for the IPC side. This change was prompted
by a tablet tool showing the calibration matrix property in the IPC
message, but not being able to actually change it since that property
was only being considered for the touch input type.
Instead of listening to both transform and scale events, we can listen
to the commit event and use the new wlr_output_event_commit struct to
decide what to do.
This de-duplicates some of the work we were doing twice when an output
was re-configured.
Depends on [1].
[1]: https://github.com/swaywm/wlroots/pull/2315
If the environment variable is not defined, getenv returns NULL.
Passing a NULL pointer to the "%s" format specifier is undefined
behavior. Even if some implementations output "(null)", an empty
string is nicer.
`!*rgba` tests if the first byte of rgba isn't `'\0'`.
`hex_to_rgba_hex` returns NULL if `parse_color` fails. There's a null
pointer dereference in that case. The intended behavior is `!rgba`.
The pointer `data` is cast to a more strictly aligned pointer type. To
prevent issues, the `data32` buffer is removed and its occurrences are
replaced with an offset from the `data` buffer.
If the mouse/cursor/pointer is near the edge of an output when a "move
position to pointer" command is run, then the floating container will be
constrained to fit inside the bounds of the output as much as possible.
This behavior matches what i3 does in this scenario. I also think it is
a better user experience.
Relates to #4906
The logic for the bounds check follows the implementation in i3: 7330778223/src/floating.c (L536)
Usually it should be enough to simply not grant a client's
minimize request, however some applications (Steam, fullscreen
games in Wine) don't wait for the compositor and minimize anyway,
getting them stuck in an unrecoverable state.
Restoring them immediately lead to heavy flickering when unfocused
on my test application (Earth Defense Force 5 via Steam), so it's
preferable to grant their request without actually minimizing and
then restoring them once they are in focus again.
On warping to a cursor hint, update the pointer position we track as
well, so that on the next pointer rebase we don't send an unexpected
synthetic motion event to clients.
Fixes#5405.
Previously, we called output_disable prior to wlr_output_commit. This
mutates Sway's output state before the output commit actually succeeds.
This results in Sway's state getting out-of-sync with wlroots'.
An alternative fix [1] was to revert the changes made by output_disable
in case of failure. This is a little complicated. Instead, this patch
makes it so Sway's internal state is never changed before a successful
wlr_output commit.
We had two output flags: enabled and configured. However enabled was set
prior to the output becoming enabled, and was used to prevent the output
event handlers (specifically, the mode handler) from calling
apply_output_config again (infinite loop).
Rename enabled to enabling and use it exclusively for this purpose.
Rename configure to enabled, because that's what it really means.
[1]: https://github.com/swaywm/sway/pull/5521
Closes: https://github.com/swaywm/sway/issues/5483
As per the Wayland spec [1]:
> The icon surface is an optional (can be NULL) surface that provides an
> icon to be moved around with the cursor.
However, as of now Sway "start_drag" signal handler does not starts the
DND session unless a non-NULL drag icons is provided. This patch fixes
it by skipping handling of the drag icon if it is null.
Fixes#5509
[1] https://wayland.freedesktop.org/docs/html/apa.html#protocol-spec-wl_data_device
Signed-off-by: Nick Diego Yamane <nickdiego@igalia.com>
xdg-shell doesn't allow clients to set the title to NULL, so we
shouldn't need to call wlr_foreign_toplevel_handle_v1_set_title with an
empty string to reset the old one.
Closes: https://github.com/swaywm/sway/issues/5488
If moving e.g. `T[app app]` into a new workspace with `workspace_layout
tabbed`, then post-move the tree in that workspace will be `T[T[app
app]]`. This still happens with horizontal or vertical workspace layout,
but is less visible since those containers have no decorations.
Fixes#5426.
It is not a part of the foreign-toplevel-management protocol to get the
class of a toplevel, only for getting the app_id.
For xwayland clients this is an issue because that means that you cannot
identify what application the toplevel refers to which is the point of
the app_id property.
By falling back to class when an app_id does not exist solves this problem.
Phoc also uses app_id and class interchangeably in their implementation
of foreign-toplevel-management, in fact they always do that and not only
for just this protocol.
c8d8a4c544/src/xwayland.c (L236)
wlr_drag installs grabs for the full duration of the drag, leading to
the drag target not being focused when the drag ends. This leads to
unexpected focus behavior, especially for the keyboard which requires
toggling focus away and back to set.
We can only fix the focus once the grabs are released, so refocus the
seat when the wlr_drag destroy event is received.
Closes: https://github.com/swaywm/sway/issues/5116
If a client commits a new size on its own, we create a transaction for
the resize like any other. However, this involves sending a configure
and waiting for the ack, and wlroots will not send configure events when
there has been no change. This leads to transactions timing out.
Instead, just mark the view ready immediately by size when the client
is already ready, so that we avoid waiting for an ack that will never
come.
Closes: https://github.com/swaywm/sway/issues/5490
Prior to this commit, a tablet device could trigger mouse button down
bindings if the pen was pressed on a surface that didn't bind tablet
handlers -- but it wouldn't if the surface did bind tablet handlers.
We should expose consistent behavior to users so that they don't have to
care about emulated vs. non-emulated input, so stop triggering bindings
for any non-pointer devices.
Ronan Pigott
Tudor Brindus
Simon Ser
Isaac Freund
Vlad Pănăzan
Paul Riou
Rex Hackbro
Brian Ashworth
Tamir Zahavi-Brunner
mwenzkowski
Dimitris Triantafyllidis
Daniel De Graaf
Tarmack
Tobias Langendorf
David96
John Mako
Rouven Czerwinski
Geoffrey Casper
BrassyPanache
Konstantin Pospelov
Antonin Décimo
Thayne McCombs
Nils Schulte
Andri Yngvason
Nick Diego Yamane
wb9688
Johan Bjäreholt
Kenny Levinsen
Drew DeVault